Showcar TV Downloads Forum Contact Links
      
Username:   
Password:   

First Test: 2013 BMW M5 Stick in the Mud

06:40AM - 20.11.'12

News Source: motortrend.com

 

North America is the only continent where you can buy the 2013 BMW M5 with a manual transmission. In that truth hides a stubborn reluctance, a hesitance from a vocal minority to adapt to the onward march of progress. The M5 wasn't designed with a manual in mind, but now, after much complaining, this $100,000, twin-turbo super-sedan is offered with a third pedal and a lever at no extra cost. We got our cake; now we're going to eat it, too. How is it? Slower. Lacking a noticeable weight advantage; the might-as-well-be-instantaneous shifts from BMW's twin-clutch (M DCT) transmission; and the effective, albeit unwieldy launch control; the manual M5 takes 4.2 seconds to reach 60 mph and 12.5 seconds to pass the quarter mile. The fastest twin-clutch-equipped M5 we tested clocked in at 3.7 seconds to 60 and 11.9 seconds for the quarter mile.  These results aren't surprising, because when you choose a manual these days, you aren't doing so to be faster -- modern twin-clutch transmissions can't be beat in shift speed. No, you choose a manual gearbox because you're about the intimacy and sensation of control that a third pedal and a lever introduces. You're a purist. But when you apply this logic to all cars, a problem arises. A sweeping, correct transmission choice doesn't exist. Rather, the choice is contextual: A Mazda Miata or a Subaru BRZ wouldn't be more fun with a twin-clutch, and a manual wouldn't make a Ferrari 458 or a Nissan GT-R better.

 

 
Showcar  |  Events  |  Gallery  |  Videos  |  Garage  |  Tech Files  |  Downloads  |  Forum  |  Contact  |  Links  
Copyright © 2026  •  www.showcar.com.au  •  Showcar Pty. Ltd.  •  Contact info@showcar.com.au sydney web design & development by Webski